the memorabilia(纪念品)-第11节
按键盘上方向键 ← 或 → 可快速上下翻页，按键盘上的 Enter 键可回到本书目录页，按键盘上方向键 ↑ 可回到本页顶部！
————未阅读完？加入书签已便下次继续阅读！
capitulate and cry 〃mercy〃 in a siegethe man of elaborate wants； or he
who can get along happily with the readiest things to hand？ You； Antiphon；
would seem to suggest that happiness consists of luxury and extravagance；
I hold a different creed。 To have no wants at all is； to my mind； an attribute
of Godhead；＇5＇ to have as few wants as possible the nearest approach to
Godhead； and as that which is divine is mightiest； so that is next mightiest
which comes closest to the divine。
＇5＇ Cf。 Aristot。 〃Eth。 N。〃 x。 viii。 1。
Returning to the charge at another time； this same Antiphon engaged
Socrates in conversation thus。
36
… Page 37…
The Memorabilia
Ant。 Socrates； for my part； I believe you to be a good and upright man；
but for your wisdom I cannot say much。 I fancy you would hardly dispute
the verdict yourself； since； as I remark； you do not ask a money payment
for your society； and yet if it were your cloak now； or your house； or any
other of your possessions； you would set some value upon it； and never
dream； I will not say of parting with it gratis； but of exchanging it for less
than its worth。 A plain proof； to my mind； that if you thought your society
worth anything； you would ask for it not less than its equivalent in gold。＇6＇
Hence the conclusion to which I have come； as already stated： good and
upright you may be； since you do not cheat people from pure selfishness；
but wise you cannot be； since your knowledge is not worth a cent。
＇6＇ Or rather 〃money；〃 lit。 〃silver。〃
To this onslaught Socrates： Antiphon； it is a tenet which we cling to
that beauty and wisdom have this in common； that there is a fair way and a
foul way in which to dispose of them。 The vendor of beauty purchases an
evil name； but supposing the same person have discerned a soul of beauty
in his lover and makes that man his friend； we regard his choice as
sensible。＇7＇ So is it with wisdom； he who sells it for money to the first
bidder we name a sophist；＇8＇ as though one should say a man who
prostitutes his wisdom； but if the same man； discerning the noble nature of
another； shall teach that other every good thing； and make him his friend；
of such a one we say he does that which it is the duty of every good citizen
of gentle soul to do。 In accordance with this theory； I too； Antiphon；
having my tastes； even as another finds pleasure in his horse and his
hounds；＇9＇ and another in his fighting cocks； so I too take my pleasure in
good friends； and if I have any good thing myself I teach it them； or I
commend them to others by whom I think they will be helped forwards on
the path of virtue。 The treasures also of the wise of old； written and
bequeathed in their books；＇10＇ I unfold and peruse in common with my
friends。 If our eye light upon any good thing we cull it eagerly； and regard
it as great gain if we may but grow in friendship with one another。
＇7＇ Add 〃and a sign of modesty；〃 ｛sophrona nomizomen｝。
＇8＇ ｛sophistas｝。 See Grote； 〃H。 G。〃 viii。 482 foll。； 〃Hunting；〃 xi。
37
… Page 38…
The Memorabilia
foll。
＇9＇ Cf。 Plat。 〃Lys。〃 211 E。
＇10＇ Cf。 〃Symp。〃 iv。 27。
As I listened to this talk I could not but reflect that he； the master； was
a person to be envied； and that we； his hearers； were being led by him to
beauty and nobility of soul。
Again on some occasion the same Antiphon asked Socrates how he
expected to make politicians of others when； even if he had the knowledge；
he did not engage in politics himself。
Socrates replied： I will put to you a question； Antiphon： Which were
the more statesmanlike proceeding； to practise politics myself single…
handed； or to devote myself to making as many others as possible fit to
engage in that pursuit？
VII
Let us here turn and consider whether by deterring his associates from
quackery and false seeming he did not directly stimulate them to the
pursuit of virtue。＇1＇ He used often to say there was no better road to
renown than the one by which a man became good at that wherein he
desired to be reputed good。＇2＇ The truth of the concept he enforced as
follows： 〃Let us reflect on what a man would be driven to do who wanted
to be thought a good flute player； without really being so。 He would be
forced to imitate the good flute player in the externals of his art； would he
not？ and first or all； seeing that these artists always have a splendid
equipment；＇3＇ and travel about with a long train of attendants； he must
have the same； in the next place； they can command the plaudits of a
multitude； he therefore must pack a conclave of clackers。 But one thing is
clear： nothing must induce him to give a performance； or he will be
exposed at once； and find himself a laughing…stock not only as a sorry sort
of flute player； but as a wretched imposter。 And now he has a host of
expenses to meet； and not one advantage to be reaped； and worse than all
38
… Page 39…
The Memorabilia
his evil reputation。 What is left him but to lead a life stale and unprofitable；
the scorn and mockery of men？ Let us try another case。 Suppose a man
wished to be thought a good general or a good pilot； though he were really
nothing of the sort； let us picture to our minds how it will fare with him。
Of two misfortunes one： either with a strong desire to be thought
proficient in these matters； he will fail to get others to agree with him；
which will be bad enough； or he will succeed； with worse result； since it
stands to reason that anyone appointed to work a vessel or lead an army
without the requisite knowledge will speedily ruin a number of people
whom he least desires to hurt； and will make but a sorry exit from the
stage himself。〃 Thus first by one instance and then another would he
demonstrate the unprofitableness of trying to appear rich； or courageous；
or strong； without really being the thing pretended。 〃You are sure sooner
or later to have commands laid upon you beyond your power to execute；
and failing just where you are credited with capacity； the world will give
you no commiseration。〃 〃I call that man a cheat； and a great cheat too；〃 he
would say； 〃who gets money or goods out of some one by persuasion； and
defrauds him； but of all imposters he surely is the biggest who can delude
people into thinking that he is fit to lead the state； when all the while he is
a worthless creature。〃＇4＇
＇1＇ ｛apotrepon proutrepen｝。 See K。 Joel； op。 cit。 p。 450 foll。
＇2＇ Cf。 〃Cyrop。〃 I。 vi。 22。
＇3＇ Or； 〃furniture of the finest；〃 like Arion's in Herod。 i。 24。
Schneid。 cf。 Demosth。 565。 6。
＇4＇ Here follows the sentence ＇｛emoi men oun edokei kai tou
alazoneuesthai apotrepein tous sunontas toiade dialegomenos｝＇；
which； for the sake of convenience； I have attached to the first
sentence of Bk。 II。 ch。 i。 ＇｛edokei de moi 。 。 。 ponou。｝＇ I believe that
the commentators are right in bracketing both one and the other as
editorial interpolations。
39
… Page 40…
The Memorabilia
BOOK II
I
Now； if the effect of such discourses was； as I imagine； to deter his
hearers from the paths of quackery and false…seeming；＇1＇ so I am sure that
language like the following was calculated to stimulate his followers to
practise self…control and endurance： self…control in the matters of eating；
drinking； sleeping； and the cravings of lust； endurance of cold and heat
and toil and pain。 He had noticed the undue licence
