theologico-political treatise p4(舞僥嚥屓嵶廨籾冩梢4)-及1准
梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
A Theologico´Political Treatise
A Theologico´Political
Treatise
Part IV of IV ´ Chapters XVI to XX
Baruch Spinoza
1
´ Page 2´
A Theologico´Political Treatise
CHAPTER XVI
OF THE FOUNDATIONS OF A STATE�察�OF THE NATURAL AND
CIVIL RIGHTS OF INDIVIDUALS�察�AND OF THE RIGHTS OF THE
SOVEREIGN POWER。
��1�� Hitherto our care has been to separate philosophy from theology�察�
and to show the freedom of thought which such separation insures to both。
��2�� It is now time to determine the limits to which such freedom of thought
and discussion may extend itself in the ideal state。 ��3�� For the due
consideration of this question we must examine the foundations of a State�察�
first turning our attention to the natural rights of individuals�察 �and
afterwards to religion and the state as a whole。
��16��4�� By the right and ordinance of nature�察 �I merely mean those
natural laws wherewith we conceive every individual to be conditioned by
nature�察�so as to live and act in a given way。 ��5�� For instance�察 �fishes are
naturally conditioned for swimming�察�and the greater for devouring the less�察�
therefore fishes enjoy the water�察 �and the greater devour the less by
sovereign natural right。 ��16��1�А。�6�� For it is certain that nature�察�taken in the
abstract�察�has sovereign right to do anything�察�she can�察�in other words�察�her
right is co´ extensive with her power。 ��7�� The power of nature is the power
of God�察 �which has sovereign right over all things�察 �and�察�inasmuch as the
power of nature is simply the aggregate of the powers of all her individual
components�察�it follows that every�察�individual has sovereign right to do all
that he can�察�in other words�察�the rights of an individual extend to the utmost
limits of his power as it has been conditioned。 ��8�� Now it is the sovereign
law and right of nature that each individual should endeavour to preserve
itself as it is�察�without regard to anything but itself �察�therefore this sovereign
law and right belongs to every individual�察 �namely�察 �to exist and act
according to its natural conditions。 ��9�� We do not here acknowledge any
difference between mankind and other individual natural entities�察 �nor
between men endowed with reason and those to whom reason is unknown�察�
nor between fools�察�madmen�察�and sane men。 ��10�� Whatsoever an individual
does by the laws of its nature it has a sovereign right to do�察�inasmuch as it
acts as it was conditioned by nature�察�and cannot act otherwise。 ��16��2�А。�11��
2
´ Page 3´
A Theologico´Political Treatise
Wherefore among men�察�so long as they are considered as living under the
sway of nature�察 �he who does not yet know reason�察 �or who has not yet
acquired the habit of virtue�察�acts solely according to the laws of his desire
with as sovereign a right as he who orders his life entirely by the laws of
reason。
��16��12�� That is�察 �as the wise man has sovereign right to do all that
reason dictates�察 �or to live according to the laws of reason�察 �so also the
ignorant and foolish man has sovereign right to do all that desire dictates�察�
or to live according to the laws of desire。 ��13�� This is identical with the
teaching of Paul�察�who acknowledges that previous to the law ´ that is�察�so
long as men are considered of as living under the sway of nature�察�there is
no sin。
��16��14�� The natural right of the individual man is thus determined�察�not
by sound reason�察 �but by desire and power。 ��15�� All are not naturally
conditioned so as to act according to the laws and rules of reason�察�nay�察�on
the contrary�察�all men are born ignorant�察�and before they can learn the right
way of life and acquire the habit of virtue�察 �the greater part of their life�察�
even if they have been well brought up�察 �has passed away。 ��16��
Nevertheless�察 �they are in the meanwhile bound to live and preserve
themselves as far as they can by the unaided impulses of desire。 ��17��
Nature has given them no other guide�察 �and has denied them the present
power of living according to sound reason�察�so that they are no more bound
to live by the dictates of an enlightened mind�察�than a cat is bound to live
by the laws of the nature of a lion。
��16��18�� Whatsoever�察�therefore�察�an individual ��considered as under the
sway of nature�� thinks useful for himself�察�whether led by sound reason or
impelled by the passions�察�that he has a sovereign right to seek and to take
for himself as he best can�察 �whether by force�察 �cunning�察 �entreaty�察 �or any
other means�察 �consequently he may regard as an enemy anyone who
hinders the accomplishment of his purpose。
��16��19�� It follows from what we have said that the right and ordinance
of nature�察�under which all men are born�察�and under which they mostly live�察�
only prohibits such things as no one desires�察�and no one can attain�此�it does
not forbid strife�察�nor hatred�察�nor anger�察�nor deceit�察�nor�察�indeed�察�any of the
3
´ Page 4´
A Theologico´Political Treatise
means suggested by desire。
��16��20�� This we need not wonder at�察�for nature is not bounded by the
laws of human reason�察 �which aims only at man's true benefit and
preservation�察 �her limits are infinitely wider�察 �and have reference to the
eternal order of nature�察�wherein man is but a speck�察�it is by the necessity of
this alone that all individuals are conditioned for living and acting in a
particular way。 ��21�� If anything�察�therefore�察�in nature seems to us ridiculous�察�
absurd�察�or evil�察�it is because we only know in part�察�and are almost entirely
ignorant of the order and interdependence of nature as a whole�察�and also
because we want everything to be arranged according to the dictates of our
human reason�察 �in reality that which reason considers evil�察 �is not evil in
respect to the order and laws of nature as a whole�察�but only in respect to
the laws of our reason。
��16��22�� Nevertheless�察�no one can doubt that it is much better for us to
live according to the laws and assured dictates of reason�察�for�察�as we said�察�
they have men's true good for their object。 ��23�� Moreover�察 �everyone
wishes to live as far as possible securely beyond the reach of fear�察�and this
would be quite impossible so long as everyone did everything he liked�察�
and reason's claim was lowered to a par with those of hatred and anger�察�
there is no one who is not ill at ease in the midst of enmity�察�hatred�察�anger�察�
and deceit�察�and who does not seek to avoid them as much as he can。 ��16��3�А�
��24�� When we reflect that men without mutual help�察�or the aid of reason�察�
must needs live most miserably�察�as we clearly proved in Chap。 V。�察�we shall
plainly see that men must necessarily come to an agreement to live
together as securely and well as possible if they are to enjoy as a whole the
rights which naturally belong to them as individuals�察�and their life should
be no more conditioned by the force and desire of individuals�察�but by the
power and will of the whole body。 ��25�� This end they will be unable to
attain if desire be their only guide ��for by the laws of desire each man is
drawn in a different direction���察 �they must�察 �therefore�察 �most firmly decree
and establish that they will be guided in everything by reason ��which
nobody will dare openly to repudiate lest he should be taken for a
madman���察�and will restrain any desire which is injurious to a man's fellows�察�
that they will do to all as they would be done by�察�and that they will defend
4
´ Page 5´
A Theologico´Political Treatise
their neighbour's rights as their own。
��16��26�� How such a compact as this should be entered into�察 �how
ratified and established�察�we will now inquire。
��27�� Now it is a universal law of human nature that no one ever
neglects anything which he judges to be good�察 �except with