湊徨勵弌傍利 > 哂囂窮徨慕 > madam how and lady why(裟健繁才山溺平) >

及29准

madam how and lady why(裟健繁才山溺平)-及29准

弌傍�� madam how and lady why(裟健繁才山溺平) 忖方�� 耽匈4000忖

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




does know�察�and knows a great deal�察�and very accurately�察�what he does not 

know is the matter itself。        He will tell you wonderful things about oxygen 

gashow the air is full of it�察�the water full of it�察�every living thing full of it�察�

how it changes hard bright steel into soft�察�foul rust�察�how a candle cannot 



                                                94 


´ Page 95´

                              MADAM HOW AND LADY WHY 



burn without it�察�or you live without it。       But what it is he knows not。 

    Will he ever know�拭�

     That is Lady Why's concern�察�and not ours。            Meanwhile he has a right 

to find out if he can。     But what do you want to ask him next�拭�

    What�拭     �Oh�     �What carbonic acid is。       He can tell you that。      Carbon 

and oxygen gas。 

    But what is carbon�拭�

    Nobody knows。 

    Why�察�here is this stupid Analysis at fault again。 

    Nay�察  �nay�察  �again。   Be   patient   with   him。  If   he   cannot   tell   you   what 

carbon is�察�he can tell you what is carbon�察�which is well worth knowing。 

He will tell you�察�for instance�察�that every time you breathe or speak�察�what 

comes out of your mouth is carbonic acid�察�and that�察�if your breath comes 

on a bit of slacked lime�察�it will begin to turn it back into the chalk from 

which   it   was   made�察  �and   that�察  �if   your   breath   comes   on   the   leaves   of   a 

growing plant�察�that leaf will take the carbon out of it�察�and turn it into wood。 

And surely that is worth knowing��that you may be helping to make chalk�察�

or to make wood�察�every time you breathe。 

    Well�察�that is very curious。 

    But now�察�ask him�察�What is carbon�拭            �And he will tell you�察�that many 

things are carbon。       A diamond is carbon�察�and so is blacklead�察�and so is 

charcoal and coke�察�and coal in part�察�and wood in part。 

    What�拭     �Does Analysis say that a diamond and charcoal are the same 

thing�拭�

    Yes。 

     Then his way of taking things to pieces must be a very clumsy one�察�if 

he can find out no difference between diamond and charcoal。 

    Well�察�perhaps it is�此     �but you must remember that�察�though he is very 

oldas old as the first man who ever livedhe has only been at school for 

the last three hundred years or so。        And remember�察�too�察�that he is not like 

you�察�who have some one else to teach you。 He has had to teach himself�察�

and find out   for   himself�察�and   make   his   own   tools�察�and   work   in   the dark 

besides。    And I think it is very much to his credit that he ever found out 

that diamond and charcoal were the same things。              You would never have 



                                             95 


´ Page 96´

                               MADAM HOW AND LADY WHY 



found it out for yourself�察�you will agree。 

     No�此   �but how did he do it�拭�

     He taught   a very  famous   chemist�察�Lavoisier�察 �about   ninety  years   ago�察�

how to burn a diamond in oxygenand a very difficult trick that is�察�and 

Lavoisier found that the diamond when burnt turned almost entirely into 

carbonic acid and water�察�as blacklead and charcoal do�察�and more�察�that each 

of them turned into the same quantity of carbonic acid�察�And so he knew�察�as 

surely as man can know anything�察�that all these things�察�however different 

to our eyes and fingers�察�are really made of the same thing��pure carbon。 

     But what makes them look and feel so different�拭�

     That Analysis does not know yet。           Perhaps he will find out some day�察�

for he is very patient�察�and very diligent�察�as you ought to be。               Meanwhile�察�

be   content   with   him�此   �remember   that   though   he   cannot   see   through   a 

milestone yet�察�he can see farther into one than his neighbours。               Indeed his 

neighbours cannot see into a milestone at all�察�but only see the outside of it�察�

and   know   things   only   by   rote�察  �like   parrots�察  �without   understanding   what 

they mean and how they are made。 

     So now remember that chalk is carbonate of lime�察�and that it is made 

up   of   three   things�察  �calcium�察  �oxygen�察  �and   carbon�察  �and   that   therefore   its 

mark is CaCO��3���察�in Analysis's language�察�which I hope you will be able to 

read some day。 

     But how is it that Analysis and Synthesis cannot take all this chalk to 

pieces�察�and put it together again�拭�

     Look here�察�what is that in the chalk�拭�

     Oh� �a shepherd's crown�察�such as we often find in the gravel�察�only fresh 

and white。 

     Well�察�you know what that was once。              I have often told you�此�a live 

sea´egg�察�covered with prickles�察�which crawls at the bottom of the sea。 

     Well�察�I am sure that Master Synthesis could not put that together again�此�

and   equally   sure   that   Master   Analysis   might   spend   ages   in   taking   it   to 

pieces�察�before he found out how it was made。               Andwe are lucky to´day�察�

for   this  lower    chalk   to  the   south   has   very   few   fossils  in  ithere   is 

something else which is not mere carbonate of lime。               Look at it。 

     A little cockle�察�something like a wrinkled hazel´nut。 



                                               96 


´ Page 97´

                                MADAM HOW AND LADY WHY 



     No�察  �that   is   no  cockle。   Madam   How   invented          that   ages   and  ages 

before she thought of cockles�察�and the animal which lived inside that shell 

was as different from a cockle´animal as a sparrow is from a dog。                   That is 

a   Terebratula�察  �a   gentleman   of   a   very   ancient   and   worn´out   family。    He 

and his kin swarmed in the old seas�察�even as far back as the time when the 

rocks of the Welsh mountains were soft mud�察�as you will know when you 

read that great book of Sir Roderick Murchison's�察�Siluria。                But as the ages 

rolled on�察�they got fewer and fewer�察�these Terebratulae�察�and now there are 

hardly any of them left�察�only six or seven sorts are left about these islands�察�

which cling to stones in deep water�察�and the first time I dredged two of 

them   out   of   Loch   Fyne�察  �I   looked   at   them   with   awe�察  �as   on   relics   from 

another world�察�which had lasted on through unnumbered ages and changes�察�

such as one's fancy could not grasp。 

     But you   will   agree   that�察  �if   Master Analysis   took   that   shell to pieces�察�

Master Synthesis would not be likely to put it together again�察�much less to 

put it together in the right way�察�in which Madam How made it。 

     And what was that�拭�

     By  making   a  living   animal�察 �which   went   on   growing�察 �that   is�察 �making 

itself�察�and making�察�as it grew�察�its shell to live in。          Synthesis has not found 

out yet the first step towards doing that�察�and�察�as I believe�察�he never will。 

     But there would be no harm in his trying�拭�

     Of course not。      Let everybody try to do everything they fancy。 Even if 

they fail�察�they will have learnt at least that they cannot do it。 

     But   nowand   this   is   a   secret   which   you   would   never   find   out   for 

yourself�察�at least without the help of a microscopethe greater part of this 

lump of chalk is made up of things which neither Analysis can perfectly 

take   to   pieces�察  �nor   Synthesis   put   together   again。    It   is   made   of   dead 

organisms�察�that is�察�things which have been made by living creatures。                       If 

you washed and brushed that chalk into powder�察�you would find it full of 

little   things   like   the   Dentalina   in   this   drawing�察  �and   many   other   curious 

forms。     I will show you some under the microscope one day。 

     They are the shells of animals called Foraminifera�察�because the shells 

of some of them are full of holes�察�through which they put out tiny arms。 

So small they are and so many�察�that there may be�察�it is said�察�forty thousand 



                                                97 


´ Page 98´

                                MADAM HOW AND LADY WHY 



of them in a bit of chalk an inch every way。                In numbers past counting�察�

some whole�察�some broken�察�some ground to the finest powder�察�they make 

up   vast   masses   of   England�察  �which   are   now   chalk   downs�察  �and   in   some 

foreign   countries   they   make   up   whole   mountains。         Part   of   the   building 

stone of the Great Pyramid   in Egypt is composed�察 �I am told�察�entirely  of 

them。 

     And how did they get into the chalk�拭�

     Ah�     �How   indeed�拭      �Let   us   think。   The   chalk   must   have   been   laid 

down at the bottom of a sea�察�because there are sea´shells in it。 Besides�察�we 

find little atomies exactly like these alive now in many seas�察�and therefore 

it is fair to suppose these lived in the sea also。 

     Besides�察�they were not washed into the chalk by any sudden flood。 The 

water   in   which   they   settled   must   have   been   

卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��0�� 家��1��

低辛嬬浪散議